'The Bachelor' Controversy Addressed

Copyright 2009 Richard Cartwright / ABC
For fans of "The Bachelor" who went from loving Jason Mesnick to being shocked at the fact that he dumped Melissa on live TV -- read on to find out what Mike Fleiss, the executive producer, has to say about Jason's action!

Mike defends the decision to air the emotional moment, saying that Melissa was not blindsided by Jason's action.

"They had been talking and seeing each other. I think it was clear to both of them that there were problems with the relationship at that point," Mike says. "As I understand it, they were all but broken up prior to the show. I don't think she knew that she was going to give him back the ring, but I think she knew they weren't going to be together."

As for why he aired it, he says, "First of all, it is a TV show and that was the defining movement of the series. To not put it on TV on would be strange when you consider we are doing a TV show and these people signed up to do a TV show. The real difference here was [that] his decision to break up with Melissa involved the other party in this situation, Molly. So it was all part of our 'Bachelor' universe. [To us] it seemed weird to turn the cameras off. We try to tell a complete story. To have that go on and not let the viewers be a part of it, I think, would have been a mistake."

That said, Mike reveals that Molly had no idea what was going to happen on "The Bachelor -- After the Final Rose." What she was told was that it was the regular update that the series does at the end of each season, and for which she had already been contracted.

What he wants to make clear is that the on-air breakup was not scripted by the show.

"We don't do that and we never will do that," he says. "The great thing about unscripted television is it is unpredictable. It caught us off guard and the viewers off guard. That is why unscripted television works. It doesn't feel pat. It doesn't feel contrived."

Jason, of course, is taking a lot of flack for his decision ... or, rather, his indecision.

"He was so immensely popular, he had the furthest to fall," Mike points out. "When he did something that the audience didn't want him to do, the audience was disappointed."

As for Molly's future with Jason, Mike says he was with the couple last night and they were as happy as can be.

"He told me, 'What was I going to do? I was in love with this girl. What was my choice? Not to pursue this woman I adore?'"

At this point in time, the "M" word hasn't been mentioned by the couple, but keep checking back for more "The Bachelor" news. If wedding bells are in Jason and Molly's future, we will report it.

Published 3/4/09 by the Insider

Comments (24)

  • orLogin
  • The Insider we want you to keep us informed of Jason and Molly. Do they have a happy ever after, or do one or both find out who the other one really is. These two are such horrible people,and I think we want to see just what happens to them after...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • This season was HBO factor. It was so gross to see him make out with every girl. Molly when he kisses you he is probally thinking of one of they other ladies he was with. This show has a huge failure rate as far as relationship makings. They need to...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • Mellisa I hope you have a great time on dancing with the stars. I pray You and Ty have a wonderful relationship. You will find tru love. Stay who you are...your a wonderful person. Jason and Molly will get what they deserve. They will break up...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • Jason have you ever heard what comes around goes around? Look deep into Molly's eyes...any woman willing to be second best,and be with someone like you after what you did to melissa is someone you should sleep with one eye open. Molly seems very...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • Jason is a horrible father figure. He should have never aloud Ty to be apart of any of this. If Jason was not sure about his decision 100% he should not have asked Mellisa to marry him, and Ty should not have been there. Jason is sending a very bad...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • Jason is a horrible father figure. He should have never aloud Ty to be apart of any of this. If Jason was not sure about his decision 100% he should not have asked Mellisa to marry him, and Ty should not have been there. Jason is sending a very bad...
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • I think Melissa's parents were wise not to be part of what turned out to be a circus. I hope Melissa does find true love. She certainly deserves it.
    Anonymous 3/6/09 Reply
  • I am glad he did what he did. Better to do it now then after marriage.
    We can't say what he went through, that show must be tough.
    Jason did put me off earlier this year though with all the kissing and necking of ALL the girls. I did find this...
    jayme13 3/5/09 Reply
  • Unfortunately there are men and women who won't take the responsibility for what they do. Melissa told Jason not to be texting or emailing her anymore which he acknowledged he knew what she was talking about. I think he was leading her on and he...
    Anonymous 3/5/09 Reply
  • jaosn look like a ..
    tsewang 3/5/09 Reply
  • how can you do this????jason you cheater, you bastard, you rediculious...you are such a nonsense guy i have ever seen in my entire life........mellisa is so nice and good caring girl...jason you dump.............
    tsewang 3/5/09 Reply
  • Well it is not nice being dumped in front of millions but, Melissa had to known that there relationship was not going anywhere from the sounds of it and when he told her that things were not right and he felt what he felt she did not at all look...
    Anonymous 3/4/09 Reply
  • None of the other break-ups were on live TV. It was in poor taste and bad judgement on your part to humiliate Melissa that way. She was crushed and Jason of all people should have shown better after the Deanna did him.. I am
    Anonymous 3/4/09 Reply
  • ........
    NeverLetGo 3/4/09 Reply
  • Jason thought he loved Melissa but later realized he didn't.Can you really expect someone to get to know someone in 6 weeks?
    Anonymous 3/4/09 Reply