'Twilight' vs. 'The Vampire Diaries'

Copyright 2009 Kimberly French / Summit Entertainment. All rights reserved.
Vampires have never been more popular on-screen what with 'The Twilight Saga' on the big screen, and "True Blood" on HBO. This fall, The CW enters the preternatural competition with "The Vampire Diaries," based on the eponymous series of books by author L.J. Smith.

 

So how do the two vampire leading men stack up against each other? ET asked Paul Wesley, who plays Stefan Salvatore in "The Vampire Diaries," if his character would win in a fight with 'Twilight''s Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson).

"I don't know enough about Edward Cullen, so I don't know what his abilities are," admits Wesley. "I think that is up to the viewer to decide once they start watching the show."

Wesley goes on to say that he purposely didn't watch the movie prior to shooting the pilot for his series, because he didn't want it to influence his performance in anyway considering the similarity in subject matter.

"And now, I've seen parts of it," he says. "I think if there are similarities to Robert Pattinson's character in 'Twilight,' so be it."

Exec producer Kevin Williamson also admits that "the premise is the same: you know, girl meets vampire. But what L.J. Smith did was once you get past that premise ... when you read the first book ... I was like, 'No way. This is 'Twilight.' But when I got to the second book, you start to realize, 'Oh, my God. Boy, this is a fork in the road. It really does separate.' So we're getting to that fork in the road really quick. And we're really sort of telling the story about a small town, all darkness that lies underneath this town and how this vampire comes to town and sort of stirs it all up."

One difference between 'Twilight' and "The Vampire Diaries" is the budget. Since the latter is a series, the producers had to come up with an inexpensive way of turning Wesley and Ian Somerhalder, who plays his brother Damon, into vampires.

"I hate cheap effects and I hate when it gets really cheesy and you don't really have really money or the time to do things to any sort of big budget scale -- and everybody who is watching this show has seen what you can do with $150 million on a feature film," Williamson says. "So it's kind of hard. We want to do something a little more subtle and just keep it to some sort of, like, biological sort of physiological response, so when they get excited we just sort of see the blood rush under the skin, pales their face out a little bit, but it all goes to the eye and they kind of have these bloody eyes. And then, of course, they have teeth."

"The Vampire Diaries" premieres Thursday, Sept. 10 at 8 p.m. on The CW.

Published 8/5/09 by the Insider

Comments (67)

  • orLogin
  • I don't care who copied who. I love them them both! Keep the hot vampire guys coming:)
    Anonymous 11/23/09 Reply
  • VAMPIRE DIARIES is better. Sorry, Steph. I like Twilight, it's just you can see how it pales in comparison to the Vampire Diaries. Elena and Stefan are a better couple, too.
    Anonymous 11/13/09 Reply
  • I luv both but Vampire diaries came first and it does seem that Twilight was a copy! I guess who cares their raking in the G's . I have talk to teenagers and they think Bella is week because how she feels towards Edward! I notice they have not...
    Anonymous 11/13/09 Reply
  • TVP books are the best! i couldn't put them down... 700x better than twilight. i couldnt even finish twilight. TVP show isnt great but nina is a great actress! so much better than kristen Stewart. TVP came out in 1991 twilight kinda copied!!!
    Anonymous 11/10/09 Reply
  • theree both qood ! :)
    Anonymous 11/8/09 Reply
  • WESLEY is so ugly!!!!!!
    Anonymous 11/4/09 Reply
  • As much as I love Twilight, I have to say I like The Vampire Diaries better. And umm have you seen Stefan (Paul Wesley) he is one sexy vampire....
    Anonymous 10/30/09 Reply
    • oh yeah....i agree
      i was obsessed with twilight before
      but things changed....the plot of VD is wayyy better and I personally think that Paul Wesley is way hotter than RPattz...way younger looking too
      Anonymous 10/30/09
  • i love new moon so much the book is intense but i love vampire diaries between the two my favourite characters are isbella- bella jacob damon edward elana
    Anonymous 10/29/09 Reply
  • I'm sorry but vampire diaries is way better! twilight was a boring movie
    Anonymous 10/20/09 Reply
  • I really want to watch Vampire Diaries but it hasn't come out in New Zealand yet. I've watched trailers on youtube and I really really want it to come to New Zealand. Does anyone know when it comes out in New Zealand?
    And I think there are some...
    Anonymous 10/20/09 Reply
  • I enjoy both! I get excited when Thursdays come around to watch Vampire Diaries and I can't wait to watch New Moon when it comes out. I don't get why people have to chose between one or the other. There are similiarities and there differences. I can...
    EleseS 10/19/09 Reply
  • im glad they pointed out that Vamp. Diaries was released before twilight. Twilight is okay, but i don't get why the author is making the entire world fall in love with Bella. HER CHARACTER IS BORING AS !! the only thing that interests me in Twilight...
    Anonymous 10/13/09 Reply
  • oh plllllllzzzzzzz ppl!!! get ur head straight! vampire diaries was written way b4 twilight and the author of twilight TOTALLY COPIED VAMPIRE DIARIES!!!!! k,look i still am or maybe was...a very big fan of the twilight books ONLY...and now VAMPIRE...
    Anonymous 10/8/09 Reply
  • edward and stefan are way too similar, but if i were to pick one to win in a fight, it would be edward for sure. bella's character is much more complex than elena, so i prefer her.
    Anonymous 10/8/09 Reply
    • are you kidding?! Edward is just wayyy to perfect that its just stupid
      and bella...well....i dont know that much about her cuz she's not explained well...her background i mean
      Anonymous 10/30/09
  • Are you serious? The Vampire Diaires and Twilight shouldn't even be in the same sentence. TVD was way better. The only reason Twilight's so big is because of "Edward" and how all the little girls drool all over him. It's stupid. What the hell kind...
    Anonymous 10/3/09 Reply