Fashion Face-Off: Ashley Tisdale vs. Holly Madison

Fashion Face-Off: Ashley Tisdale vs. Holly Madison
Thanks to her new nose, it’s difficult to even recognize Ashley Tisdale.

But we’re pretty sure that is the High School Musical star below, shimmering in a dress from this year’s American Music Awards.

Looking similar to the young singer/actress? One of Hugh Hefner’s Girls Next Door, as Holly Madison shows off her assets in a silver sequined dress at a recent holiday party in Los Angeles.

Once you decide if the clothed Playboy Bunny looks better than Tisdale, let us know if Holly Madison nude is more attractive than Carmella DeCesare nude.

ShareThis

Published 12/21/07 by

drift82 79 drift82

DISCLAIMER: This posting was submitted by a user of the site not from The Insider editorial staff. All users have acknowledged and agreed that the submission of their story and its contents is in compliance with our Terms of Use.

Comments (32)

  • orLogin
  • ASHLEY TISDALE IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL!!!
    Anonymous 8/5/09 Reply
  • Ashley is more beautiful,,, the other girl looks so aweful!!!! ewWWWQ@ she's like a very OLD WOMAN...huhuhu!!!!
    Anonymous 7/29/09 Reply
  • holly has more curves and fills out the dress better, but ashley looks more conservative in still a sexy way
    Anonymous 5/26/09 Reply
  • I LOVE U ASHLEY,U R SO COOL N U ALWAYS LOOK GREAT!PLEASE EMAIL ME!
    Anonymous 4/30/09 Reply
  • ok guys first of all learhow 2 speak english ! and of cource ashley looks way , way better than that t !come on now !there's something , holly that you put in front of your fake boobs . is called a bra!! lool
    Anonymous 4/28/09 Reply
  • what? holly is better ashley is a bich and ugly.
    holly is wanderfull and gorgerous
    Anonymous 4/12/09 Reply
  • holly madison! she has better legs better boobs just a better body and her hair looks good. ashley's hair looks nappy and dirty. plus holly's dress is way cuter than ashley's dress.
    Anonymous 4/5/09 Reply
  • lol Some of you people suck at telling others off. And half of ya'll need to learn how to spell.
    But yeah, Holly is prettier but Ashley looks....decent? Except for the hair. Holly's hair is 100% better. Ashley also looks like a snobby prep.
    Anonymous 3/26/09 Reply
  • I'm a girl and have to say that HOLLY LOOKS WAY BETTER!! Ashley's just a lil girl, Holly is a woman and has it all.. wow! Wish I was her.. :)
    Anonymous 3/11/09 Reply
  • Ashley Tisdale is looking so fly in that dress. she is giving Holly Madison a run for her money. you go girl. :-)
    Anonymous 3/9/09 Reply
  • askley u are so kwl your film is da best xxxx ad me beckyinnit@hotmail.co.uk 4 a friendly chat
    Anonymous 2/27/09 Reply
  • Ashley Looks much better!!! No contest. Holly Madison just looks way to y.
    Anonymous 2/13/09 Reply
  • Ashley looks waaayyy BeTtEr!!!!
    Anonymous 12/4/08 Reply
  • Ashley looks tons better!
    Holly should put on more or better clothes.
    Anonymous 11/28/08 Reply
  • Omg!! the other girl lloks better but Ahely is beautiful also!
    Anonymous 11/27/08 Reply
View More Comments
Write a Comment