American Idol

American Idol

Add as a Favorite

(This poll has ended)
Pictures: Kara DioGuardi

What do you think of American Idol adding a fourth judge - Kara DioGuardi - to the panel?

  • I think it's great. We're so many seasons into Idol, it will be good to have a fresh voice on the panel.
    40%
  • No! Sure she's a songwriter and has industry perspective, but don't fix what ain't broke. Randy, Simon and Paula have their thing going on and a fourth judge will totally change the dynamic.
    60%

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (4)

  • Most people would love to see the beautiful
    Ali & Lindsay Lohan as judges.
    anonymous anonymous 8/25/08 Reply
     
  • I'm so upset tis is happening! WHy did they have to change the idol formate? i loved it just beening Randy Ryan Paula and Simon I don't want this dumb kara being there! I hate her for destroying idol!
    gossipgirlie 388 gossipgirlie 8/26/08 Reply
     
  • Maybe they should have differnt guests Actors/musicians to take turns helping judge the idols. I would like to hear what they'll have to say!
    anonymous 103 rubi1181 8/28/08 Reply
     
  • Hey you guys just hate Kara with no reason, maybe just because all of Kara hater are Paula fans..FYI, Paula and Kara is a very good friend. Give her a break!
    Let Kara do her job!!
    I love Kara, she is good and capable to be AI judge!
    So far she did great in AI. Go Kara!
    AyuningK 8 AyuningK 4/23/09 Reply