American Idol

American Idol

Add as a Favorite

(This poll has ended)

Which American Idol winner do you think has the best voice?

  • Kelly Clarkson Pictures: Kelly ClarksonKelly Clarkson
    26%
  • Ruben Studdard Pictures: Ruben StuddardRuben Studdard
    2%
  • Fantasia Barrino Pictures: FantasiaFantasia Barrino
    6%
  • Carrie Underwood Michael Phelps, Pictures: Carrie Underwood Woos Michael PhelpsCarrie Underwood
    39%
  • Taylor Hicks Pictures: Taylor Hicks: I'm Bringing the Soul Patrol to BroadwayTaylor Hicks
    4%
  • Jordin Sparks Russell Brand, Pictures: Jordin SparksJordin Sparks
    8%
  • David Cook Pictures: David CookDavid Cook
    14%

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (209)

  • UMM Hello jodrin sparks is DA BEST EV-AHHHHHHH...OMG THE SONG No Air ya im ubsessed with it and the song tatto but hey thats just me. u guys better get a better taste for next time
    anonymous anonymous 9/30/08 Reply
     
    • You are so wrong because jordin sparks only has 10% and Carrie underwood has 37% so hahaha and go head and be angry because i dont care
      anonymous anonymous 3/26/09
       
  • Just based on the awards and how far she has already gotten proves that Carrie Underwood is unstoppable. Everyone who is on this list deserves to be here except Taylor Hicks. He is a Discrase to the American Idol name.
    ChrystalL 6 ChrystalL 10/1/08 Reply
     
    • You souldn't post until you learn how to spell.
      anonymous anonymous 1/18/09
       
    • Don't be a moron, learn to spell first, then clean out your ears. Taylor Hicks has a great voice, he won, didn't he?
      anonymous anonymous 4/14/09
       
    • uh, miss "anonymous", YOU learn how to spell if you're going to criticize someone elses spelling! it's SHOULDN'T not souldn't!
      anonymous 43 mrslautner 6/20/09
       
  • CARRIE FOREVER!!!!!!!
    SVU123 1995 SVU123 10/2/08 Reply
     
    • I agree with you she is so good especially her song " before he cheats" that song is the bomb
      anonymous anonymous 3/26/09
       
  • I went to Carrie's concert in Delaware, What a show!!! She is off the Chart's in my eyes. I will see her live every chance I get.
    anonymous anonymous 10/4/08 Reply
     
  • The best is David Cook.
    anonymous anonymous 10/4/08 Reply
     
    • you are so right David is the BEST
      anonymous 5 kylebusch 10/23/08
       
    • david cook is the best..he going to be HUGE soon...trust me..
      anonymous anonymous 3/27/09
       
  • Jordin.
    anonymous anonymous 10/5/08 Reply
     
  • Shes great, and can sing anything
    obxclw 34 obxclw 10/5/08 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood all the way!
    anonymous anonymous 10/15/08 Reply
     
  • jORDIN! =]
    anonymous anonymous 10/21/08 Reply
     
  • David is the Best singer I have ever witnessed,and I could listen to him for endless hours, he has it all, can't wait to purchase all his singles and albums
    anonymous 5 kylebusch 10/23/08 Reply
     
  • I see Carrie has lots of votes, but I just can't listen to hear, I don't like her voice at all, also I don't like country songs, they are always about cheating,love to anothers wife or husband, dying, moaning , just stupid thingsgroning
    anonymous 5 kylebusch 10/23/08 Reply
     
    • I like country, but to me Carrie is not country. I don't like her voice either.
      anonymous anonymous 1/18/09
       
  • where is my Bear Reuben these days?
    anonymous anonymous 10/24/08 Reply
     
    • nobody cares about ruben anymore
      anonymous anonymous 6/15/09
       
    • nobody cares about ruben anymore
      anonymous anonymous 6/15/09
       
    • nobody cares about ruben anymore
      anonymous anonymous 6/15/09
       
  • We are so deeply saddened to learn of Jennifer Hudson's terrible loss - so very sad. We are keeping you in our thoughts and prayers Jennifer. God bless you and your family during this time ...see more
    anonymous anonymous 10/25/08 Reply
     
  • I voted for Kelly Clarkson, with Carrie Underwood a close second.Both women are very sexy.
    anonymous 2652 GeorgeJobson 10/25/08 Reply
     
  • i don't really mind but I think Jordin sparks i well kwl
    anonymous 64 disneygirl 11/10/08 Reply
     
  • I think people must take Kelly Clarkson 4 granted. r u kidding? she is the BEST! she's the 1st winner & obviously the best. HANDS DOWN.
    anonymous anonymous 11/11/08 Reply
     
    • I Agree With You 100%! She Is The Best! And Doesnt Follow The Pack At All.Thats Why I Love Her!!!!! Kelly Fan All The Way!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • Carrie is the only one I have heard sing
    anonymous 6 carriefanatic 11/16/08 Reply
     
  • Carrie is THEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE best IDOL EV-AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH...nearly 10 million album sales in 3 yrs, Before He Cheats, Last Name, Just a Dream, HELLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
    anonymous 6 carriefanatic 11/16/08 Reply
     
  • I saw her live in San Diego, she was beyond awesome, not to mention, she is SMOKIN' HOOOOOOOOOOOOOT
    anonymous 6 carriefanatic 11/16/08 Reply
     
  • I saw her live in San Diego, she was beyond awesome, not to mention, she is SMOKIN' HOOOOOOOOOOOOOT
    anonymous 6 carriefanatic 11/16/08 Reply
     
  • i think david cook is the man. i wish we can have lunch r better yet , i can cook him a good home meal. bb
    anonymous anonymous 11/17/08 Reply
     
  • The best voice is Kelly Clarkson. Not only can she sing everything fantastic, but her "voice" includes being able to write the most amazing lyrics and melodies.

    For proof just listen to "Irvine" or "Because of You"

    VOICE - A medium or agency of expression.
    anonymous anonymous 11/20/08 Reply
     
  • Call me wierd, but I like the 'Bama boys...Ruben and Taylor... Ruben has an amazingly smooth voice...Taylor's....amazingly gravely and interesting....not like the average pop star voice.
    anonymous anonymous 11/24/08 Reply
     
  • Taylor Hicks without question!
    anonymous anonymous 11/24/08 Reply
     
  • Taylor HIcks is the best IMO
    anonymous anonymous 11/24/08 Reply
     
  • There are a couple of good ones, but, Taylor Hicks is by far my favorite. He is unique and not just another "pop" sound like everybody else. David Cook is my 2nd choice.
    anonymous anonymous 11/25/08 Reply
     
  • It's Taylor Hicks for me.
    anonymous anonymous 11/26/08 Reply
     
  • Kelly - no question!

    She has amazing range and she's SOOOOOO versatile. She can sing pop, country, soul, rock, even big band!!!!!!!!!

    Versatility is one major aspect of "best voice" because most of these people sing different genres, but Kelly can sing every one of the genres that the others sing.
    anonymous anonymous 11/29/08 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood is a great singer, and really cool. She has A LOT of fans, so i can see why shes winning. But honestly in terms of vocal range, flexibility and talent you have to give it to Kelly Clarkson. Carrie's vocal cords would rupture if she tired singing some of Kelly's songs the way Kelly does. Don't confuse talent with popularity.
    anonymous anonymous 11/29/08 Reply
     
  • I love em all they all have beautiful voices if I had to vote i vote em all they all a tie.
    Gailjohnson360 92 Gailjohnson360 11/30/08 Reply
     
  • go hicks! sound great. rbafrica@comcast.net
    anonymous anonymous 12/2/08 Reply
     
  • 1.Kelly
    2.Carrie
    anonymous anonymous 12/3/08 Reply
     
  • Kelly is #1 ,Carrie is #2, Jordin is #3
    anonymous anonymous 12/3/08 Reply
     
  • yup! but d best voice is carrie underwood
    anonymous anonymous 12/5/08 Reply
     
  • yup! but d best voice is Carrie Underwood!
    anonymous anonymous 12/5/08 Reply
     
  • Carrie has great and amazing voice....
    her songs motivate me and help me to see through my problems..
    go carrie...
    vote for carrie....
    anonymous 10 lip6 12/18/08 Reply
     
  • i dont even remember the only i do is jordin sparks because she still famous
    anonymous anonymous 12/19/08 Reply
     
  • It doesn't get much better than David Cook. A joy to listen to.....and I'm 65 and grandmother of 8. Love Carrie too. :o)
    anonymous anonymous 12/30/08 Reply
     
  • Fantasia hands down. Still the #1 performer on all news polls. Congrats on all her success!
    anonymous anonymous 1/12/09 Reply
     
  • Taylor is the top of the heap. Going to see him Saturday in Chicago. He's been all over the news here the last two weeks.
    anonymous anonymous 1/15/09 Reply
     
  • Hey fat chrystall, you are the one who is a disgrace. Taylor is The American Idol Winner with the BEST VOICE.
    anonymous anonymous 1/16/09 Reply
     
  • Taylor Hicks,...an original voice!
    anonymous anonymous 1/16/09 Reply
     
  • taylor is absolutely the best. but i love them all. gooo taylor!
    anonymous anonymous 1/17/09 Reply
     
  • TAYLOR HICKS!!!!! Taylor has the complete package , looks, personality, voice and he is so entertaining. Congratulations to all of the winners, but Taylor is my favorite.
    anonymous anonymous 1/18/09 Reply
     
  • Fantasia has the best pure vocals, but Taylor has the most original , unique voice of the bunch.
    anonymous anonymous 1/18/09 Reply
     
  • This pole is definitely falling to favorites and not who actually has the best voice. Carrie is an amazing country singer and will be around for years to come in that genre. However, her vocals don't even come close to comparing with those of Kelly Clarkson. She is hands down the best vocalist to come out of the franchise. If not for her...we would never had made it to season 4 to even meet Carrie Underwood. Those thinking Taylor Hicks is the best...need your hearing checked.
    anonymous anonymous 1/27/09 Reply
     
    • I totally agree with you!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
    • I totally agree with you!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • hello jordin, you ar the best. i love to have your kinda voice. love you so much
    anonymous anonymous 1/28/09 Reply
     
  • CARRIE UNDERWOOD HAS NO TALENT! SHE IS NOT BETTER THAN KELLY CLARKSON! I DON'T LIKE TAYLOR EITHER BUT I THINK HE'S BETTER THAN CARRIE!! CARRIE NEEDS TO GO BACK TO OKLAHOMA! I HATE CARRIE! CAN'T STAND HER!!
    MartinaMFan 93 MartinaMFan 1/30/09 Reply
     
    • SHE CANT STAND YOU EITHER!!! THERE AINT NOBODY BETTER THAN CARRIE SWEETHEART EVEN SIMON SAID THAT!!! YOU HAVE NO TALENT EITHER! LOOK AT YOU POSTING MEAN THINGS ON AN IDOL WEBSITE YOU FRUIT LOOP! GOD ALMIGHTY!
      anonymous anonymous 5/9/09
       
    • Taylor is a joke of American idol. he would be just ok if he was like a 50-60 yr old man ,but he is not. Tayl;or cannot carry a tune and you notice he was a loud to ear plugs because he needed all the help he could get. Carrie Underwood is fantastic. I think that Taylor H. is worst singer. . My dog can sing better Taylor.
      anonymous anonymous 6/7/09
       
    • MartinaMFan, do you not like Carrie because she has taken away Martina's thunder. I am sorry to tell that Martina is outdated and her songs are not that good. She can sing but she needs better material. Carrie is the best at the momnt and will be here for a LONG time!
      anonymous anonymous 7/13/09
       
  • CARRIE UNDERWOOD, Has the best voice by far,
    She is a reining country music superstar.[proves she can sing].
    biggest fan club. Sold out concerts, flawless.before he cheats,is one of the biggest cross-overs. and never once lip-song..unlike some other winners. that shouldent have won.

    kellie picker should have won over saggy hicks
    David Cook is a good choice.

    but, jordin whines in every song. kelly cant decide what range she wants. Ruben and hicks are a joke. and fantashia ? She isent a good singer at all.
    anonymous anonymous 2/8/09 Reply
     
  • I love original voices when not every one sound the same. Carrie has a very unique voice.
    JaniceM2 49 JaniceM2 2/13/09 Reply
     
  • PUH-LEESE!!! FANTASIA IS THE BEST AMERICAN IDOL WINNER HANDS DOWN! Her voice is authentic and anointed....two things that equal greatness. I bet you out of all these American Idol winners, Fantasia will go down in music history as a music icon. Jennifer Hudson already took the cake on that one! But Fantasia is nothing to play with. But to rank these from best to least would be: Fantasia, Carrie, Kelly, Ruben, Jordin, Taylor, and David (I've never heard David Cook, so I don't know how he sounds).
    trishrenee06 44 trishrenee06 2/22/09 Reply
     
    • Fantasia sucked. The only reason she won that year was her incessant blubbering. I hear that she is wanted for impersonating a Kool-Aid pitcher.
      anonymous anonymous 2/22/09
       
  • She has more energy!!
    anonymous 7 StephenC10 2/23/09 Reply
     
  • bull crap
    fantasia is the best voice out of alll of them but it's ok when all the AI ppl lose their "voice" on stage fantasia will still have hers
    anonymous anonymous 2/23/09 Reply
     
  • I am glad you picked carrie underwood she is very good great singer I really like her alot i love carrie as a fan Melissa Tatomir
    anonymous anonymous 2/27/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie has all the votes coming to her
    anonymous anonymous 2/27/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie will forever be the best!!!! Her voice is just amazing!!! Love her!!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/6/09 Reply
     
  • I would love to have Kelly and Carrie do a song toghetherit would be number 1 overnight how about donating bthe proceids to thear favorite charity Gerry the 63 fan
    anonymous anonymous 3/18/09 Reply
     
  • With so many known singers in the pop world...I think it was harder for Kelly to made her mark. Country singers are less known...therefore it was easier for Carrie to become quickly known. Kelly's the best!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/18/09 Reply
     
    • I Second That! Cause There Really Are So Many Pop Singers In The World. Its A Harder To Become Known, But Country Music Is Not As Popular And When Carrie Won, She Was The Only Winner To Go Country.
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • Taylor and Ruben won for popularity reasons. Clay should have beat Ruben hands down!!!!! I don't care for Taylor at all. Jordan is ok as well as the rest. But Kelly will always be the original AI. Carrie is also good. They both won for obvious reasons. The only difference is the genre of music they sing. But if I had to choose just one.....I'd say KELLY CLARKSON rocks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/18/09 Reply
     
    • You got that right!!! Clay was the Idol that year
      !!
      anonymous anonymous 8/5/09
       
    • You got that right!!! Clay was the Idol that year
      !!
      anonymous anonymous 8/5/09
       
    • You got that right!!! Clay was the Idol that year
      !!
      anonymous anonymous 8/5/09
       
    • You got that right!!! Clay was the Idol that year
      !!
      anonymous anonymous 8/5/09
       
  • ... I think he has the best voice bec. not only can he change the genre of the song ex. from pop to rock and most importantly make it a more hit song than the former...
    anonymous anonymous 3/18/09 Reply
     
  • david cook is unstoppable
    anonymous anonymous 3/18/09 Reply
     
  • i don't like Carrie but I'll admit she has a good voice.
    anonymous anonymous 3/19/09 Reply
     
    • carrie doesnt like you either! Carrie Marie Underwood forever and always baby!
      anonymous anonymous 5/9/09
       
  • David Cook has it all!! The voice, the look, the wit, the humor, the kindness.. you name it!
    anonymous anonymous 3/19/09 Reply
     
  • He didn't win but Clay Aiken has the best voice.
    seriara 7 seriara 3/19/09 Reply
     
  • to be honest he's the only one that DOESN'T scare me...see more
    anonymous anonymous 3/20/09 Reply
     
  • Jordin is the best ever!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/22/09 Reply
     
  • Taylor Hicks and Kelly Clarkson all the way. Both have the whole package. The hotness would have to go to Taylor and Carrie.
    anonymous anonymous 3/24/09 Reply
     
  • I love kelly clarkson so much. she is the Very First American Idol, 4 Grammy Awards, She was originally marketed as a pop musician with her debut album Thankful (2003). With the release of her multi-platinum second album, Breakaway (2004), Clarkson moved to a more pop rock-oriented style of music.[1] Clarkson's third album, entitled My December, was released on June 26, 2007. According to Sony Music, Clarkson has sold over 20 million albums worldwide.[2] Clarkson has had eight of her singles become Top ten hits on the Billboard Hot 100.
    anonymous anonymous 3/24/09 Reply
     
  • Taylor Hicks is beyond compare. Therefore, he has the best voice, best charisma, and overall best entertainer and therefore, the best total package, bar none.....To ChrystalL, you are the DISCRAESE.....I love Carrie but I honestly sometimes do not recognize her voice. One can recognize Taylor's voice the minute you hear the first word.
    anonymous anonymous 3/24/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie, then David, Then Kelly and then Taylor!!!!!!!!
    SueS16 36 SueS16 3/24/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood is cute and has a good voice but not near the quality of a voice as Fantasia.
    anonymous anonymous 3/24/09 Reply
     
  • Idol is boring since Carrie,by all means she's the best,look at the awards she's gotten,awesome is all i can say.Keep it up.
    anonymous 6 rowdy 3/25/09 Reply
     
    • if Fantasia is/ was so great why do you not not hear anything about fantasia anything about her. How can someone do a life story at age 24 that's plain ridiculous. \a likely story is about some person that has had a fab. carrier, which fantasia has not ,she needs to grow up and live maybe if she gets better a whole lot better then a slim chance they MIGHT IF SHE IS LUCKY AND VERY SUCCESSFUL. THEY MIGHT DO ONE.
      anonymous anonymous 6/7/09
       
  • I really think that carrie underwood does have the best voice because she stand up and lets it out without even trying to make it louder
    anonymous anonymous 3/26/09 Reply
     
  • carrie is awesome! a true american idol
    anonymous anonymous 3/27/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly rocks cannot stand Carrie Underwood! She is FAKE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/28/09 Reply
     
  • David Cook is amazing, there are no words to explain his talent.
    anonymous anonymous 3/28/09 Reply
     
  • CARRIE UNDERWOOD SUCKS!!! she sounds like a dying cow!!
    anonymous anonymous 3/31/09 Reply
     
    • WHY BE MEAN
      anonymous 271 TAMPAGRANNY 3/31/09
       
    • YOU SOUND LIKE A DYING COW! WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU?? SHES A SINGER SHE MADE IT!! YOUR JUST MAD!
      anonymous anonymous 5/9/09
       
  • Hello, its got to be Carrie Underwood with the best voice!
    anonymous anonymous 4/3/09 Reply
     
  • I absolutly LOVE Carrie Underwood so I will stand by her 100% So of course I vvoted for Ms. Carrie Underwood
    anonymous anonymous 4/4/09 Reply
     
  • I still think Bo Bice should have won!!!
    anonymous anonymous 4/6/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood has become a screamer. She sounds strained and you can hardly understand her. If she sings softer songs it helps her.

    My favorite of all the seasons was not the American Idol winner and that would be Daughtry! He is definately the best to come out of all the shows.
    anonymous anonymous 4/9/09 Reply
     
  • CARRIE underwood for sure she has awesome songs and she rocks no matter what. my 2nd favorite is jordin sparks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!.
    anonymous anonymous 4/12/09 Reply
     
  • They are all fantastic! They each have their special, unique style that enabled them to rise to the top!
    anonymous anonymous 4/12/09 Reply
     
  • It is truly amazing to see the quality of the constestants grow from year to year. I would say without a doubt, that several of the previous years winners, should not have won, as they definitely did not have the best voices.
    anonymous anonymous 4/13/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie is EASY to look at, but I hate how the radio ruins her songs by repeating them over and over again. Chris Daughtery has the best voice from AI history, hands down.
    anonymous anonymous 4/14/09 Reply
     
  • Here's the deal - Kelly and Carrie are both immensely talented, however since their vocal styles are so different, it's hard to choose between the two of them. The others are all good, but none of the rest of them compare to Kelly and Carrie.
    anonymous anonymous 4/14/09 Reply
     
  • When it comes to best vocal, it has to be David Archuleta..... He is the best........!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 4/16/09 Reply
     
  • carrie underwood is the best.......
    anonymous 6 carlcute142 4/17/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood won the "Entertainer of the Year" award!!!! So Carrie Underwood is the best American Idol (yet)!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
    anonymous 11 OllyPollys5 4/17/09 Reply
     
    • Thats A Year! Not A Lifetime! So It Realy Doesnt Mean Shes The "BEST", It Just Means She Did What The Record Label Told Her To Do Like A Puppet! She Cant Do Anything! God I Hate How People Compare People By Awards! Its By The FANS!!!!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
    • Thats A Year! Not A Lifetime! So It Realy Doesnt Mean Shes The "BEST", It Just Means She Did What The Record Label Told Her To Do Like A Puppet! She Cant Do Anything! God I Hate How People Compare People By Awards! Its By The FANS!!!!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • I love Carrie and Kelly. They are the two best and I love them both!!
    anonymous 669 Grams 4/21/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie is awesome!
    anonymous anonymous 4/22/09 Reply
     
  • carrie's voice like a donald duck at song last name.. kelly rules!!!!!! that's just polling can manipulation!!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 4/24/09 Reply
     
    • you prolly sound like donald duck when you talk so what. She gets paid for it.
      anonymous anonymous 5/9/09
       
  • DAVID COOK all the way!! He's the only one up there that has the total package......and he's hot as hell!

    Also, I hate Carrie...she's such a self-absorbed bitch! I cringe everytime I see her win an award.
    anonymous anonymous 4/27/09 Reply
     
  • oh well it doesn't matter who won at least they all got a chance to win the american idol but i like jordins"one step at a time"..
    anonymous anonymous 4/27/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly is the best shes versatile & has an amazing voice. Shes the best..
    anonymous anonymous 4/29/09 Reply
     
  • KELLYYYYYYYYYYYY ROCKS!!!!!!!!!
    anonymous 6 nona69 5/1/09 Reply
     
  • KELLY IS MOST DEFINITELY THE BEST AND MOST SEXIEST SINGER!!JUST ASK HER WIFE RENEA RAMIREZ IN BEEVILLE,TX...KELLY IS THE BOMB!!!!! LATERZZZ. NONA
    anonymous 6 nona69 5/1/09 Reply
     
  • Widen your horizons-learn to appreciate all kinds of music. Taylor Hicks has a unique voice and style. He should be respected & appreciated for HIS talent. He does have talent & America agrees.
    anonymous anonymous 5/1/09 Reply
     
  • I think they all are great. However, I still love my girl Fantasia! I do love Carrie, Judin, and Ruben though.
    anonymous anonymous 5/2/09 Reply
     
  • What? No Clay Aiken? He'd be my vote!
    anonymous 4155 LoriS8 5/4/09 Reply
     
    • and yes.... I know he didn't win, but still the most spectacular voice I ever heard on that show....
      anonymous 4155 LoriS8 5/4/09
       
    • Clay didn't eed the AI title to get it done-Saw his Christmas Show in 2005- Walked out thinking Somebody pinch me!!!!
      anonymous anonymous 8/5/09
       
  • personaly i think that they should go until season 10 and put all of the idol winners on a show and have them compete. kelly clarkson can sing anything she wants to even simon said that. but about her range, the girl has a huge range. she's good and i don't think people should slam her becuase she has an awesome voice. i don't know if people are jealous or what but she is slammed way too much over everthing she does. she could be the best singer in the world and it still wouldn't be enough for a lot of you all.
    anonymous anonymous 5/5/09 Reply
     
  • The question should read: "WHO IS THE BEST OF MALE VOCALISTS/IDOLS??" DAVID COOK OWNS THE AI CROWN FOR VERSATILITY, HE CAN SING POP, ROCK THEATRE WITH EQUAL TALENT AN ORIGINALITYLIKE NO OTHER! AND THATS WHY HE WON WITH 56 million votes!
    anonymous anonymous 5/5/09 Reply
     
  • The question should read: "WHO IS THE BEST OF MALE VOCALISTS/IDOLS??" DAVID COOK OWNS THE AI CROWN FOR VERSATILITY, HE CAN SING POP, ROCK THEATRE WITH EQUAL TALENT AN ORIGINALITYLIKE NO OTHER! AND THATS WHY HE WON WITH 56 million votes!
    anonymous anonymous 5/5/09 Reply
     
  • The question should read: "WHO IS THE BEST OF MALE VOCALISTS/IDOLS??" DAVID COOK OWNS THE AI CROWN FOR VERSATILITY, HE CAN SING POP, ROCK THEATRE WITH EQUAL TALENT AN ORIGINALITYLIKE NO OTHER! AND THATS WHY HE WON WITH 56 million votes!
    anonymous anonymous 5/5/09 Reply
     
    • Yuuppp! Now were talking! :D
      anonymous anonymous 7/11/09
       
  • DAVID COOK OWNS THE AI CROWN!!
    anonymous anonymous 5/6/09 Reply
     
  • Cook & Carrie are da best!!!!!! Cook set the bar for originality .....no one has reached it yet this season 8. Adam & Chris come close. Go David...love Carrie.
    anonymous anonymous 5/6/09 Reply
     
  • Give me a break ! Carrie Underwood is completely overrated !!
    anonymous anonymous 5/6/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie is the best thing thats ever came out of idol! Kelly has a pretty voice but the others shouldnt have even tried! Miss Carrie Underwood all the way baby!
    anonymous anonymous 5/9/09 Reply
     
    • HAHAHAHAHA, If It wasnt for Kelly making it big, there would be no show, and no Carrie!(like thats a bad thing!!!) And AI has alot to be thankful for for kelly clarkson! She showed what can happen if you win AI and Have a GREAT voice! Like Kelly!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • You people need to get a life! Carrie is and forever always be the best idol! Soo give it up! David sucked, Fantasia sucked, Taylor sucked, Ruben sucked, And uh Jordin just needs to shut up! Kellys pretty good too. But i dont see ANY of the other idols doing anything with their carrier! Carrie has won soo many awards you cant even count them anymore.. SHE IS THE BEST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED TO IDOL!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 5/9/09 Reply
     
  • david cook is really hot and i will hug him and say i 'm sorry
    anonymous anonymous 5/10/09 Reply
     
  • Fantasia ane Kelly is the best.
    anonymous anonymous 5/11/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly beats them vocally and in songwriting as well. she can sing any thing, sold the most, has the most awards, most successful, most popular world wide. if it wasn't for her Idol would have ended after the first season. David and Carrie tie for 2nd for me.
    anonymous anonymous 5/11/09 Reply
     
    • I Agree 100%!!!!!!!!!!!!
      anonymous anonymous 8/14/09
       
  • No doubt , the American idol has the best voice is Kelly Clarkson
    anonymous 16 EmmaC18 5/12/09 Reply
     
  • yeaaa Carrie is theeeee best baby forever and always!
    anonymous anonymous 5/13/09 Reply
     
  • CARRIE IS ""COUNTRY'S ENTERTAINER OF THE YEAR"".SHE IS ALSO THE BEST, I JUST LOVE HER!
    JOANNASANDERSR 10 JOANNASANDERSR 5/15/09 Reply
     
  • hands down kelly clarkson
    anonymous anonymous 5/16/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly CLARKSON has the best voice by a mile...

    even SIMON COWELL said she did....
    anonymous anonymous 5/19/09 Reply
     
    • mmm-hmm girlfriend
      anonymous anonymous 5/19/09
       
  • Kelly Clarkson! she rapes Carrie with her voice
    anonymous anonymous 5/19/09 Reply
     
  • Adam is the best!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 5/20/09 Reply
     
  • carrie underwood wishes she could sing like kelly clarkson.i don't know how anybody could favor that voice over kelly's.carrie sounds like she is singing through her nose.and please she is not all that .
    anonymous anonymous 5/22/09 Reply
     
  • There is absolutely no #@%*% way Kris Allen should be the winner of American Idol!! Adam Lambert can sing him under 20 tables and deserves the title!! I know it.You know it. The judges know it and Kris knows it. They should allow the judges to override this decision.
    anonymous anonymous 5/23/09 Reply
     
    • Agreed-But like Clay-Adam doesn't need the AI crown to make it
      anonymous anonymous 8/6/09
       
  • carrie underwood has the most butefull songs
    also she has the star look
    sand man will always sport you!!!!!
    anonymous 7 sandman0009 5/24/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie is THE best idol so far!!!!! Can't imagine anyone doing better than her. :)
    anonymous anonymous 5/26/09 Reply
     
  • An amazing voice and a lovely guy too
    anonymous anonymous 5/30/09 Reply
     
  • Totally awesome voice........
    LourdesB2 10 LourdesB2 5/30/09 Reply
     
  • Well, personally I prefer Kellie Pickler to any of them and she didn't even win!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 6/1/09 Reply
     
  • i have watch this show from day one.by far carrie underwood has the best voice. i love david cook also, he has a great voice.i haven't seen anything written here about chris daughtry! their have been so many people from idol that have made it big. i loved adam this year but i do think chris grew on the show to become the winner. i could not believe that adam hadn't been seen or heard before idol!
    anonymous 7 martha1024 6/5/09 Reply
     
  • I think and know that Carrie Underwood has the best overall voice and talent. has any of the other idols have 10 #1 straight every song that she released has go0ne #1 either mediabase or mostly billboard. She it so down to earth she is my pick and I am not the only saying that, which other idol has accomplished what Carrie has. Carie is country's entertainer of the year she has won more than 65 awards some of those awards are 4 grammy's and album of the year, female vocalist 3 times each at the cma and the acm's. she is also a triple crown . that is just to name very few awards.
    anonymous anonymous 6/7/09 Reply
     
  • David Cook
    anonymous 52 LeBaggeLady 6/8/09 Reply
     
  • Give me Taylor's voice any day. All you have to do is listen to him sing "Maybe You Should" from his latest CD "The Distance" and you'll know what I mean. It is so beautiful and deserves more notice. Plus he's great in person, too. He's the whole package! The voice, charisma, and personality! IMHO he's the best ever. The others are just "same old, same old, we've heard it before" Taylor has a uniqueness that's worth listening to.
    anonymous anonymous 6/12/09 Reply
     
  • i love you so much i just love you carrie I wont to get married you I am your marrige carrie Please send me an email back now I love you so much I like you alot
    anonymous anonymous 6/12/09 Reply
     
  • kellys sold over 20 million records!WORLDWIDE!incredible!carrie is very popular in her respective genre but kc is the ONLY idol to have worldwide success,she is a true superstar and is amazing live yeah no question about it..KELLY CLARKSON!!seriously KC is the koolest most loyal to her fans everywhere :)
    anonymous anonymous 6/14/09 Reply
     
  • Fantasia is my favorite. Her version of "Summertime" was peerless.
    Kelly is my second favorite. I think Carrie Underwood has a good voice, but she has absolutely no personality. The most boring Idol of all.
    anonymous anonymous 6/15/09 Reply
     
    • i realy dont care about the winners because i fell in love with jason castro
      anonymous anonymous 6/15/09
       
  • Go Carrie!
    anonymous anonymous 6/15/09 Reply
     
    • Serriously!!!!
      anonymous anonymous 7/9/09
       
    • Love her!!!!=]
      anonymous anonymous 7/9/09
       
  • Go Carrie!
    anonymous anonymous 6/16/09 Reply
     
  • its really hard to choose! theyre all so great! but i dont really like taylor hicks that much!
    anonymous 43 mrslautner 6/20/09 Reply
     
  • CARRIE UNDERWOOD IS THE BEST SINGER/SONGWRITER KNOWN TO MAN! I AM BY FAR HER BIGGEST FAN AND SHE IS A-M-A-Z-I-N-G!!!!!! i can't believe her wonderful talent and beauty!!!!!!!! A lot of people are saying she is anorixic but I know it is not true. You are the best!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 6/20/09 Reply
     
  • KELLY CLARKSON! OBVIOUSLY
    SHE IS KNOWN EVERYWHERE BECAUSE OF HER VOICE, HERE IN MY COUNTRY WE JUST KNOW HER, AND NOT BECAUSE SHE WAS ON AMERICAN IDOL
    anonymous anonymous 6/22/09 Reply
     
  • omg ur the best american idol that won i love u so glad u won
    anonymous anonymous 6/22/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly can sing 'every' style, so eat that everyone! And if you don't think so, look that stuff up. Im not partial to any of them, but when it comes down to the most qualified and talented singers; Kelly's number 1.
    anonymous anonymous 6/23/09 Reply
     
  • KELLY CLARKSON no doubt about it.

    She's also got a great ear for music as well.
    anonymous anonymous 6/23/09 Reply
     
  • Go Carrie!!
    anonymous anonymous 7/8/09 Reply
     
  • Hands-down, Kelly Clarkson has the best, overall voice. She can do country and way more. Carrie Underwood is basically a country star. Kelly has a lot of appeal, too, as a nice person and fun to be around and very down-to-earth. I think this is no contest.
    anonymous anonymous 7/9/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood is one of my fav. singers!
    anonymous anonymous 7/9/09 Reply
     
  • Jordin has the best voice! Go Jordin!
    anonymous anonymous 7/11/09 Reply
     
  • Umm, hellooo people!! Have you ever heard David Cook sing? I could listen to him foreveer and I wouldnt get bored. His voice is heavenly! Forever and ever Cookiee!
    anonymous anonymous 7/11/09 Reply
     
  • who has sold the most records and won the most awards ? CARRIE UNDERWOOD THATS WHOO! BEAT THAT SUCKERS :P
    anonymous 6 Taylorw0915 7/11/09 Reply
     
  • she is always on top..
    the best but not bad for carrie underwood..i think she's also amazing..
    rock on
    JebsenG 16 JebsenG 7/11/09 Reply
     
  • i love your voice, fantasia

    i think your voice is unique
    anonymous anonymous 7/14/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie has a good voice, but Kelly Clarkson has a great voice. There is no comparison.
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/09 Reply
     
  • Sabog ba kyo!!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 7/26/09 Reply
     
  • She has the looks and the talent.
    anonymous anonymous 7/27/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood hands down she has this one
    tsexxiee 182 tsexxiee 7/27/09 Reply
     
  • kelly i luv your voice
    anonymous anonymous 7/27/09 Reply
     
  • What a beautiful talented person you are Carrie, I love every song you sing and cant wait to hear more. You are my idol forever. Please keep singing and making our lives so much better by listening to you. love Penny
    anonymous anonymous 8/1/09 Reply
     
  • Reuben WHO????
    Clay Aiken was the winner that year-Second place didn't hinder his stardom a bit !!
    anonymous anonymous 8/5/09 Reply
     
  • David Cook by leaps & bounds!!
    CyndieE 11 CyndieE 8/6/09 Reply
     
  • Undoubtably!! Carrie underwood!!
    anonymous anonymous 8/13/09 Reply
     
  • Kelly Clarkson is the one and only American Idol. She puts all the others to shame. She has the most amazing vocals, and songwriting ability. She can sing all genres. She is famous internationally (she has sold as many abroad as in the U.S) and has sold more than any other "Idol". Her voice gives me chills, no other singer does that. There is no comparison. SHE IS ALSO THE BEST SINGER LIVE.
    anonymous anonymous 8/13/09 Reply
     
  • Carrie Underwood is so boring and fake. How is she winning this poll????? Yuck. The worst.
    anonymous anonymous 8/13/09 Reply
     
    • What are you smoking?
      anonymous anonymous 8/15/09
       
  • KELLY CLARSON IS THE BEST ONE EVER
    I LOVE HER SO MUCH
    SHE KNOW HOW TO CONTROL THE STAGE
    WAY TO GO KELLY
    coolgirl 395 coolgirl 8/15/09 Reply
     
  • Nobody cares about ruben or fantasia the only great singer is carrie. I never did like fantasia her screaming gives me a headache and ruben he is to lazy to have a career.
    anonymous anonymous 8/15/09 Reply
     
  • Taylor Hicks is the only Idol to facinate me, and I love his voice, his heart and soul, and his amazing LIVE Performances. He won because he is talented and a truly unique Entertainer, and America loved him. But there were some AI Producers that did not want him to be the winner, so they did not promote him the way they usually do the winner. What a shame! He is still a STAR cause everybody is still talking aobut it, and he is creating his own company to release great music and Entertaining Broadway Crowds, and is on National Tour since his win.
    Carrie however is cute, and she has a great voice, and country radio really wanted their share of the America Idol Pie - so Carrie got the Idol Machine promotion, and it really worked. Now she has lots of awards, and Idol got their superstar to brag about - but it should have been Taylor Hicks - and I predict it still will be...stay tuned!!!
    anonymous anonymous 8/16/09 Reply
     
  • Come on! Everyone knows Taylor Hicks rules! The man rocks! He broke the mold on Idol, and continues to show the world how things are done right! Goooo Taylor!
    anonymous anonymous 8/17/09 Reply
     
  • kelly has a beautiful voice and thats why she is still on the charts
    anonymous anonymous 9/14/09 Reply
     
  • I prefer Kellie Pickler myself.
    JackM10 6 JackM10 9/20/09 Reply
     
  • I prefer Kellie Pickler myself.
    JackM10 6 JackM10 9/20/09 Reply
     
  • i think kelly clarkson is grat i
    anonymous anonymous 9/26/09 Reply