(This poll has ended)
Copyright 2008 Gustavo Caballero / Getty Images
American Idol auditions... Cruel or hilarious?
-
Cruel! They all have harsh words for the contestants... especially Simon.30%
-
Hilarious! Are you kidding? This is the only part of American Idol that I actually watch!70%
Add Your Comment
Comments (14)
-
I actually watch the show from beginning to end. Anyone that goes on the show knows that Simon is harsh - and he needs to be. Paula and Randy can be too nice.
-
I think this whole thing in Goodman's death is just getting way out of hand. I can't believe they're trying to stick the blame on Idol for something that happened THREE YEARS AGO!!! Don't you think she would have all ready killed herself if it really was Simon's "mean" comments that drove her to kill herself?????
-
the auditions are the best part i stop watching after their over
-
Simon is a little harsh but Paula is worthless, she makes little sense. When she is finally finished talking you have no idea what she though of the performance.
-
The horrible singers are hilarious!!!
-
Simon is teling the truth pint blank. I like his sincere comments.
-
If Simon left, I will stop watching the show. The other three are totally useless and awfully boring judges.
-
the show would be nothing without Simon
we also could do without the new judge Paula , randy and simon are just fine. -
Simon is funny and usually right, Randy is repetaive however often right, Kara - fresh air, articulate and often right as well, and Paula - well....Paula needs to be gone from the show....enough of her senseless comments
-
Simon can be advertantly rude, but he is what makes the show, just as Chef Gordon Ramsey makes Hell's Kitchen entertaining.
Lay off of Paula, she has improved a lot since rehab forpain killer addiction! -
I love the auditions...the actual show is to see who has the most talent but the auditions are to see who will show up and make complete fools of themselves to be on tv...funny stuff!
Simon is great, Randy is great but Paula makes us watch the show just to see what she will say next...definitely a star player that we don't want to lose...Sorry Cara I don't really enjoy the addition of a 4th judge...The original 3 judges should be the ones that stay! -
I dont like Ellen and I dont watch her show. So I dont intend to watch American Idol. It used to be a good show and noe it is crap!
-
I dont like Ellen and I dont watch her show. So I dont intend to watch American Idol. It used to be a good show and noe it is crap!
-
I dont like Ellen and I dont watch her show. So I dont intend to watch American Idol. It used to be a good show and noe it is crap!
Related Poll
Would You Miss Paula if She Left American Idol?
Subscribe to our RSS Feed
Follow us on Twitter
