American Idol

American Idol

Add as a Favorite

(This poll has ended)

Was Fantasia's performance on American Idol the other day a bit too over the top?

  • Yeah, it was kinda ridiculous!
    78%
  • Not at all, she was just being her usual self!
    22%

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (11)

  • Her performance eccentric and unappealing it's no wonder she has had not much music success since being discovered on idol. It was appaling actually. She is the #1 chicken dancer in the US though.
    anonymous anonymous 5/16/08 Reply
     
  • She doesnt know how to sing and she should of never won american idol. thats just my opinion.
    anonymous anonymous 5/18/08 Reply
     
  • Her fifteen minutes of fame are over. The braces, pink hair, and a 30 pound weight gain equals disaster, I was shocked Simon didn't foam down the stage for that car wreck. Syesha is a total case act and I wish she was going up against one of the David's
    anonymous 45 MikeC 5/18/08 Reply
     
  • she can sing but i never did like her voice, it just irritate my ears, sorry but it's like coming from her nose or somewhere and kinda weird sound.
    anonymous anonymous 5/19/08 Reply
     
  • yea i was like every guy must of thought they were in a strip club like did you see simons face! she hardly even sang i think the only worlds she said were"AAAAA' "OOO"!
    gossipgirlie 393 gossipgirlie 5/19/08 Reply
     
  • i was really disgusted to see so many comments on youtube saying it was good. her dancing was the worst. amy adams should have won that year!!!
    anonymous anonymous 5/20/08 Reply
     
  • just plain stupid
    anonymous anonymous 5/21/08 Reply
     
  • Did you see the look on Simon's Face?
    Sweeneytodd1994 115 Sweeneytodd1994 5/21/08 Reply
     
  • Never liked her voice nor her masculine body movements when she'd sing. Guess she needs exposesure and a job and someone thought it was a great idea. Simon's face said it all. He liked Fantasia and not Jennifer Hudson. But Oprah sure took a liking to Fantasia. Got her performing on Broadway in Color Purple.
    anonymous 97 clearlight44 5/23/08 Reply
     
  • never did understand how/why she won-she is was and still is horrible
    anonymous anonymous 5/23/08 Reply
     
  • I must say Fantasia girl do your thang girl cause you have some haters that just sit on their rumps and don't do nothing but hate cause they don't have a life.
    anonymous anonymous 5/21/09 Reply