Poll Results

(This poll has ended)

Do you agree that the Miley Cyrus Vanity Fair pictures were a "mistake"?

  • Yes, she never should have done that.
    56%
  • No, the pictures were tasteful and the criticism overdone.
    44%

Add Your Comment

Your email address (will not be published, but is required):

Your comment:

No links or abusive language please!

Add Comment

Comments (35)

  • She is a teenager, an underage child...I don't care how much money she makes, how famous she is, or who her daddy is. She had no business making those pictures...shame on Vanity Fair, for even doing a photo shoot! Read your magazine now???...Yeah, right!!
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
    • THANK YOU!
      she is a YOUNG girl
      - and dont all you little 15 year olds say this was a right step for Miley-
      a 15 year old has NO buisness being shown in an "artisitic" aka. half nude way
      plus that whore has to learn her lessons how many slutty private pics are we gunna see before she learns?
      anonymous anonymous 7/25/08
       
    • Exactly!!!! She's only 15!!!! What the heck?
      Vanity Fair cover, all her private pics, Miley please!!! By the time you learn the lesson is gonna be too late.
      anonymous anonymous 7/29/08
       
  • 1.too much mascara and whats wrong with her lips.
    2.that was wrong
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
  • i agree on giving her a break but this don't give the right to take this picture she is very beautiful and she shouldn't use her body like this.
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
  • these pictures are artsy.
    the real focus should be on her sluttttty myspace pics.
    seiously miley, I'm getting tired of this. learn your lesson already, whooore.
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
  • She's an underage child. Can't believe it's legal. Where was Chris Hansen (NBC's "To Catch a Predator") in this??? LOL. Cyrus' prefer an audience of pedophiles rather than tweens.
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
  • I, personally, am not a hater (like some are) on Miley. But, this was just stupid! Is she too dumb to realize that her audience is what 5-11 year olds. She obviously doesn't think before she makes her actions, because if she did she wouldn't have had to say sorry for making parents all over upset with her. She really must not be that smart and she is truely representing Disney in the wrong way. Also, this isn't the first time she takes stupid pics. like these. No offense, but she is a tad obsessed with pulling her shirt up for her own camera, no one wants to see your stomach! Hope she turns around real quick and cease acting like she doesn't know what she's doing.
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
    • Well, maybe she doesn't know what she's doing. The point is, her father, who was on set, never should have let those photos be shoot. But he did. Annie Leibowitz should never have shot those photos. But she did. Her editor should never have allowed those photos to go to print. But he did. And the Editot-In-Chief should never have allowed that spread to be published. But she did. Miley Cyrus is not yet 16. People need to stop blaming her and calling her horrible names that she shouldn't even hear. It's the greedy people that I listed that are to blame. And money is their motivation. They knew that the issue would sell because of how disgusting this country is. It's their fault. Not hers.
      PamelaB 26 PamelaB 7/23/08
       
  • what puke she needs to go play with her barbies
    anonymous anonymous 7/22/08 Reply
     
  • She should have never done that! Shes just a kid!
    anonymous anonymous 7/23/08 Reply
     
  • OK Miley HIT THE SEX AND THE NUDE PIC OR MOVIES

    LETS ROOOOOOOOOCK ...... I LOVE U Miley
    anonymous anonymous 7/23/08 Reply
     
  • I dont see anything wrong with these pictures. Its not like she's posing naked. I personally think these pictures are very creative, and people need to give this situation a rest.
    anonymous anonymous 7/23/08 Reply
     
  • She is covered. For God's sake people...let it go! Get over it.
    anonymous 6 stingstungme 7/23/08 Reply
     
  • She can't sing her songs are bad.
    anonymous 11 sheckler 7/23/08 Reply
     
    • I couldn't agree with you more.
      anonymous anonymous 7/28/08
       
  • what kind of example is she trying to make, not a very good one if you ask me! I'm over her already!!
    della 555 della 7/24/08 Reply
     
  • It was tastefully done.I am an fine artist, and the photo reminded me of the little girl for the musical "Les Miserables". It was very tastefully done.Yes it showed her back and shoulder, but her breasts were covered and the portrait looked like it was a candid photo taken when she just came out of the shower and was caught.It was not naughty or pornographic.It was not as suggestive as Natasha Kinski's photo taken with the Boa Constrictor in the 1980's when she was 14.. No one really complained on that photo...Maybe Annie Liebewitcz was trying to make the photo a bit "artsy" or bring Miley up from the "down home redneck mentality" that alot of people have of her.It was very creative and not at all pornographic,.The Americans society is a bit backward when it comes to nudity.They have the "holier than thou" attitude and make a mountain out of an ant hill.
    anonymous anonymous 7/24/08 Reply
     
  • when i saw this on the news i was like she did not do that!!!
    anonymous 34 jonasbros98 7/24/08 Reply
     
  • well sheckler u better SHUTUP!!!!
    anonymous 34 jonasbros98 7/24/08 Reply
     
  • I rly don't thk she should have done that because well for one thing she doesn't look that great and she shouldnt get a reputation of being a whore or posing nude its not rly good and appropiate for her viewers cause their young.....you kno disney so come on miley have more sense in that and think about what your doing before you do it.
    anonymous anonymous 7/24/08 Reply
     
  • WHAT WAZ SHE THINKING. SHE WAZ A ROLE MOLDEL TO ME.NOT ANY MORE!!! U AER SO NAUGHTT!!
    anonymous anonymous 7/25/08 Reply
     
  • Trur colors have come out. Stick a fork in her - she's done.
    anonymous anonymous 7/25/08 Reply
     
  • leave the girl alone hell she is just having fun and it is her decioson on what she wants to do with her life she wants to get naked let her hell look at the playboy centerfolds yall dont critize them maybe when she is 18 she will pose for playboy lets hope so
    anonymous anonymous 7/25/08 Reply
     
  • she shouldn't have done it in the first place! and yes i think that she will end up like paris, nicole, and all the other's!
    anonymous 12 AndreaMarie 7/27/08 Reply
     
  • I think the issue is a past happening and Miley, her family and friends need to be left alone about the picture so they can heal.
    anonymous anonymous 7/28/08 Reply
     
  • I don't see the reason for them. Our society today can't handle a young women on the cover that seem undressed. I don't see the art in it. It didn't capture her beauty either. She's much prettier then that picture let's on. But hey, she's young, can't expect her to be perfect, let her live it down.
    anonymous 282 Karisma 7/29/08 Reply
     
  • I THINK SHE'S A RETARDED PERSON THAT DOESN'T UNDERSTAND ANYTHING. SHE RUINED HER CAREER THAT'S HER LESSON.AND BILLY HOW CAN YOU ALLOW YOUR DAUGHTER TO DO THESE KIND OF THINGS . NOW I UNDERSTAND WHY NICK DOESN'T WANT YOU!!!!!!!
    anonymous anonymous 7/29/08 Reply
     
  • She is a teenager. it doesnt matter that she does this. I know plenty people that are 15 and sexually active. The big point is for her image it doesn't matter but for Disney it does. I can understand that this is obscene for a 15 year old that stars in Disney for purposes that you do not want your daughter turning into a "slut" well truth is. they will be introduced into this anyways. No matter where you live, no matter what school your child goes to.your child is subjected to this! and all environments are equal in some form or fashion. I have traveled across the nation from ghetto slums to multi-million dollar ! the environments are somewhat different but things like this you cannot run from.
    anonymous anonymous 1/5/09 Reply
     
  • buy_viagra3617@yahoo.com
    anonymous anonymous 2/9/09 Reply
     
  • I think it's a BIG mistake and she can't sing
    anonymous anonymous 3/3/09 Reply
     
  • it is her rite to do what she what and if you don, like it you can go suck 1
    anonymous anonymous 3/12/09 Reply
     
  • I think so because they are all posed, but im a huge fan so i dont know
    anonymous anonymous 3/13/09 Reply
     
  • immobilie6830@yahoo.com
    anonymous anonymous 3/15/09 Reply
     
  • billy ray cyrus is a fat ass and a hog of money that ass he took all the in money from the dam world and he wants more ps miley u rock love pussy
    anonymous anonymous 8/5/09 Reply